12th Young Thinkers’ Meet (YTM) 2023

18-19 August 2023

Guwahati, Assam

India Foundation organised the 12th Young Thinkers Meet on 18-19 August, 2023 in Guwahati, Assam. Young Thinkers Meet (YTM) is one such initiative of the India Foundation that began its journey in 2012 at Coorg, Karnataka. The annually held event acts as a confluence of young nationalistic minds hailing from varied walks of life across India.

To give some context, YTM is an annual get-together organised by India Foundation, a New Delhi based think tank, for individuals (mostly under 35 years) who are driven by the idea of a New India. YTM today has an alumni base of over three hundred individuals who belong to different parts of India and come with unique life experiences and skill sets. There are social activists, political activists, NGO workers, academics, journalists, scientists, corporate professionals and students from reputed international universities. Participants in the YTM come from all parts of the country and indulge themselves in deliberations and debates on issues of contemporary national importance. The format of the meet is immersive and experiential rather than a lecture-based classroom format. The number of delegates at any YTM has varied from seventy-five to eighty-five and involves freewheeling discussion over two to three days. Each year YTM moves to a new location and helps the young delegates explore the incredible diversity of the country. The meet has previously happened in Coorg, Karnataka; Manesar, Haryana; Pune, Maharashtra; Pachmarhi, Madhya Pradesh; Patnitop, Jammu & Kashmir; Vadodara, Gujarat; Kasauli, Himachal Pradesh; Chilika, Odisha; Pahalgam and Srinagar, Jammu & Kashmir and Annavaram, Andhra Pradesh. Due to the national lockdown, YTM happened virtually in 2020.

The 12th YTM in Guwahati, Assam, aimed to bring together motivated youth leaders, emerging scholars, and potential pioneers from various sections of the Indian society to engage in challenges to our contemporary discourse and deliberate on their significance, impact and legitimacy. The engagement over two days gave a glimpse into such debates and helped our young scholars to further think over and articulate their views. The objective of the Young Thinkers’ Meet was twofold. One was to understand the global orientation of wokeness in its current weaponized form and how it proliferates Indian discourse, thereby triggering cultural wars, and who are its actors in political ideologies, corporate organizations, or other actors such as in social media. Two, consequently, the aim was to debate, discuss and understand how our youth can individually and collectively respond, and equip themselves to think anchored in Indian thought.

This YTM also included a special feature- “Border Expeditions Programme”. A group of 14 delegates selected by India Foundation were sent to the border areas of Arunachal Pradesh from 13-16 August, 2023.

The 12th Young Thinkers Meet 2023 at Guwahati, Assam was attended by 84 delegates from 22 states. Most of the delegates arrived at the venue by the evening of 17 August 2023. Followed by Dinner, an informal Introductory Session took place in which the delegates introduced themselves. The session was conducted by Shri Mukunda CR, Sah-Sarkaryavah, Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, and Dr Ram Madhav, President, India Foundation.

On 18 August 2023, the 12th Young Thinkers Meet started with the Inaugural session on “What is Woke Narrative?” featuring a distinguished panel including Shri Biswajit Daimary, Speaker-Assam Legislative Assembly; Swamini Vimalananda ji, Acharya, Chinmaya Mission, Coimbatore; Shri B. L. Santhosh, National General Secretary, BJP and it was chaired by Dr Ram Madhav, President, India Foundation. The session aimed to shed light on the contemporary relevance of the “Woke” narratives. The focus was on how wokeism has set the stage for cultural wars and has initiated a struggle for hegemony over the control of narratives, gaining momentum in Western academic institutions and challenging established social constructs.

The session commenced with Dr Ram Madhav speaking about the emergence of wokeism as a critical juncture in the ongoing cultural strife, notably visible within Western academic institutions. With an emphasis on wokeism’s disruptive nature, Dr Madhav expounded how this ideology disrupts societal norms, challenging conventional orders.

Shri Biswajit Daimary offered a deep exploration of India’s cultural diversity. He celebrated the nation’s mosaic of cultures, advocating for their acceptance and integration. Daimary ji’s exposition included references to folklore, such as the tales from Mahabharata, exemplifying how these narratives contribute to India’s cultural mosaic.

Swamini Vimalananda brought a distinct perspective by dissecting the contrasting realms of wokeism and dharma. She charted the journey of wokeism, originating as a response to marginalized groups, but ultimately morphing into a path for a specific version of justice and empowerment that suits the western narrative. Expressing concern over the dominance of Western narratives, Swamini ji urged India to forge its narrative, fostering proactive engagement instead of reactive defensiveness.

Shri B. L. Santhosh provided an illuminating account of the implications of wokeism on society. He underscored the delicate balance between cultural preservation and necessary evolution. He examined how woke culture’s propagation is often driven by market forces, leveraging digital platforms and social media to further its narrative.

The Inaugural session was followed by the first Panel Discussion on “Political Correctness, Cancel Culture and Challenges to Freedom of Expression/Wokeism on Campuses”.

The discussants of the session were Shri Ujjwal Deepak, Former OSD to Chattisgarh Chief Minister; Ms Mahamedhaa Nagar, Spokesperson, Uttar Pradesh BJP; Shri Karan Kataria, LLM, London School of Economics & Political Science (LSE); Shri Pratik Suthar, National Convener, Think India and Ms Mangla Tekam, Member, Student Wing, ABVP.

The broad themes covered in this session included the significance of our traditions and how wokeism and the wish for being politically correct has affected our own culture. The channelisation of the process of political correctness has been ingrained in our political history and it has turned toxic for our own society. The effect of postmodernism as the product of the theory of cultural marxism is being used as a tool by the woke intellectuals in universities and social institutions. The session also covered the aspect of growth of cancel culture and the medium through which the concept of wokeism spreads in the mindset of the individuals.

The second Panel Discussion was on “The Role of Media in Shaping Cultural Narratives (Media, Social Media, OTT, Television, Cinemas)”.

The panelists of the session were Dr Swadesh Singh, Assistant Professor, Satyawati College, University of Delhi; Shri Sudarshan Ramabadran, Visiting Fellow, India Foundation; Shri Apurv Mishra, Consultant, Prime Minister’s Economic Advisory Council; Ms Shruti Pandey, Research Scholar, University of Hyderabad and Shri Nishant Kumar Azad, Senior Correspondent, Organiser.

The session mainly covered several topics of shaping the cultural narratives and their building through our own way of storytelling. The issue of representation of distorted narratives of our culture and traditions by the use of mainstream media platforms and its consequences on young minds of the country was included. It also covered the aspects of how Indian Cinema has been used as a medium to spread wokeism and Hollywood movies being used as a platform to propagate biased stances on woke issues. Another thing that was highlighted was how Indian Cinema could be used as a medium to set the narrative and also how narrative building involves three steps of representation, selective reporting and setting the agenda.

After two panel discussions, a presentation session took place on “Understanding our Northeast India”. The session was chaired by Dr Shristi Pukhrem, Senior Research Fellow, India Foundation. The session was judged by Shri Mukunda CR,  Sah-Sarkaryavah, Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh; Dr Ram Madhav, President, India Foundation and Ms Rami N. Desai, Distinguished Fellow, India Foundation. All the delegates were divided into eight groups, each group representing the north-eastern states of Sikkim, Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Manipur, Nagaland and Tripura respectively. The main aim of this session was to engage participants in a group discussion and to gain some insights about the states.

Followed by group presentations, there was an open house session with Shri Mukunda CR, Sah-Sarkaryavah, Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh where young delegates had a fair and frank discussion about the theme of 12th Young Thinkers’ Meet.

After Dinner, the delegates involved themselves in a “Mock Parliament” session. All the delegates were divided into two groups, one being the Ruling Government and the other was the Opposition.

On 19 August, 2023, the day started with a visit to the auspicious Kamakhya Devi Mandir which is an Adi Shakti Peetha.

The third panel discussion was on “Gender Identity and Inclusion: Policy Challenges”. The discussants of the session were Ms Rami N. Desai, Distinguished Fellow, India Foundation; Shri Gopi Shankar Madurai, South Representative of the National Council for Transgender Persons with the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment, Government of India; Shri Ankit Bhuptani, Founder, Queer Hindu Alliance; Shri Shubhendu Anand, Advocate, Supreme Court of India and Ms Anmol Mahajan, Research Fellow, India Foundation.

The session covered the changing aspects and facets of gender and identity and a brief explanation on gender identity and womanhood. It also included the issue of the constitutionality of identification of sex of a person and also about the living reality of the LGBTQIA community and how the community is dealing with the contemporary socio, political and woke narratives. One other aspect covered was about the LGBTQIA community and their struggles with legislative process and also non-sensitisation of the masses towards them.

After the third panel discussion, there was an interaction session with Shri Gyanendra Pratap Singh, IPS, Director General of Police, Assam. He gave a very insightful presentation on “Assam’s Journey to Peace and Prosperity” in which he discussed various aspects including public order and major issues in Assam. The presentation was followed by an interactive Q&A session.

The interaction was followed by Presentations on Border Expedition. A total of 14 people selected by India Foundation were divided into two groups for the “Border Expeditions Programme” from 13-16 August, 2023. One group was sent to Tawang and the other one to Walong in Arunachal Pradesh. Both the teams gave a group presentation, sharing their experiences about visiting the border areas of Arunachal Pradesh to try and understand the topography of their land and have a first hand experience of the socio-cultural livelihood of the locals. The presentations were chaired by Shri Aaditya Tiwari, Visiting Fellow, India Foundation.

The 12th Young Thinkers Meet ended with the Valedictory Session on “Constructing an Agenda for the Future”. The speakers were Dr Ram Madhav, President, India Foundation and Shri PVSLN Murty, Member, Governing Council, India Foundation..

The session ended with a collective aim of constructing our own narratives through building academic discourses and acknowledging the importance of knowledge and love that our culture infuses in our way of life. We should work on solutions and move one step forward from just discussing our issues.

Roundtable Discussion on “Conservatism, Nationalism and Democracy”

Under the aegis of India Foundation, Conservatives’ Collective organised a roundtable discussion on “Conservatism, Nationalism and Democracy” on 26 July, 2023. The keynote lecture was delivered by Dr Yoram Hazony, Chairman, Edmund Burke Foundation and President, Herzl Institute, Jerusalem. The session was chaired by Dr Ram Madhav, President, India Foundation and moderated by Prof Shri Prakash Singh, Director, South Campus, University of Delhi.

Conceptually ‘conservatism’, ‘nationalism’ and ‘democracy’, are different yet an inextricable linkage between the three have become earnest discourse in contemporary times. More often, this stem from a spurious drive to deceptively misplace the connections between the three. In the wake of mainstream discourse which hinges around incongruent relation between nationalism and democracy, how conservatism is appropriately placed with them has generated great deal of fervour among academicians, policy analysts and journos. Hitherto conservatism is seen through a combined prism of nationalism and democracy. In this context, the “Conservative Collectives” has endeavoured to investigate various discourses pertaining to the relationship between ‘conservatism’, ‘nationalism’ and ‘democracy’ and expose the erroneous understanding and interpretation by developing deep insight with conceptual objectivity and theoretical underpinning.

The foundational notion stands on the premise that the concept of traditions and customs are at the core of traditional nationalistic conservative thought. Edmund Burke describes conservatism as an “approach to human affairs which mistrusts both a priori reasoning and revolution, preferring to put its trust in experience and in the gradual improvement of tried and tested arrangements.” Against this backdrop, a modest beginning of the “Conservative Collectives” on the platform of India Foundation took place with enlightening presentation on the subject by Dr Hazony, who, as a core supporter of ‘conservative nationalism’, talked about the historical basis of development of the ‘hegemony of enlightenment liberalism’. Discussing contemporary times, he mainly focused on the timeline of 2016 to 2020, when competing political visions were given space to come forward against the dominating ideology of liberalism and marxism. He has been hoping that national conservatism would provide restoration of political stability and freedom of thought in all the nation-states.

Dr Yoram Hazony initiated his lecture by speaking about his career, which has revolved around the study of the philosophy of Jewish Bible, the history of the state of Israel and similar subjects. In 2016, his Jewish professor from the United States encouraged him to publish on the concept of nationalism. He published his book titled “The Virtue of Nationalism” in 2018 and his second book on “Conservatism: A Rediscovery” in 2022. He also spoke about the “National Conservatism Conference”, an initiative of the Edmund Burke Foundation since 2019 to strengthen the principles of national conservatism in Western countries. Dr Hazony spoke about ‘enlightenment liberalism’ that has been dominating the western ideology since the second World War, and also pointed out that since 2016, ‘national conservatism’ has been a new and powerful force in the West. Though the conservative approach has been gaining strength in intellectual, academic and political circles, there is a need to further concretise and replenish its academic and political base.

Dr Hazony spoke about the Hebrew Bible and Judaism to bring forth an understanding of the origins of nationalism and the Jewish traditions associated with its conceptualisation. He explained about the Christian Bible which consists of the Old Testament constituting 80% of the Bible and the rest is covered by the New Testament which is basically the gospel and doctrine of Jesus. Jews do not believe in the New Testament, nor in the traditions relating to it. The Jewish Bible (basically the Old Testament) describes the origin of the nation, which begins with the creation of the world. The majoritarian ideology of the West of personal salvation of the individual soul, which has been the mainstream Christian ideology, is completely absent from the Jewish Bible.  According to Dr Hazony, the basic pillar of mankind is the idea of one nation which could provide blessings for other nations, and it does not necessarily have to be achieved through warfare and hatred.

Dr Hazony explained that the cornerstone of the Jewish political understanding is the unification of diversified tribes, the formation of a collective. He pointed out that all nations form as a collection of tribes. The western political theory has shifted the focus of this political understanding towards the concept of homogeneity, thus un-familiarising the present world with the traditions through which the nation state has emerged.

According to Dr Hazony, the traditional form of nationalism in Judaism consisted of, firstly, a structuring of diversified tribes which came together through their recognition of a unifying heritage that could be different things in different nations in the form of religion, language, shared ancestry and law. Secondly, this shared history provided the force for struggle towards common enemy and commemorating the memories of the collective triumphs and also solidarity against common disasters. These two factors, according to Dr Hazony, constituted a traditional Jewish understanding of the nation. This interpretation of traditional nationalism and nation in the Jewish Bible is entirely opposite to the enlightenment liberal series of Locke, Hobbes and Rousseau,  whose theories have propagated that state builds up the nation.

Dr Hazony said that the nation is innate even with all the internal struggles. He compared this understanding with the Christian Bible which states that the state is unified for a period of greatness, but then it splits as the brothers go to war against one another and in the end the kingdom is destroyed. The course of the western history went through the conquest of the Mediterranean by the Roman empire and then the Christians taking over the Roman Empire. After almost 2000 years, said Dr Hazony, that what we have been calling ‘West’ has been shaped by the Christians. All of great empires – the Egyptians, the Babylonians, the Syrians, the Persians, and the Romans, the origin of each one has been unique but they all functioned with the same core ideology that God provided visions to the king for conquering the four corners of the Earth to bring peace and prosperity to the mankind. The Jewish Bible has been completely against this political theory of conquering the world to bring peace, and the dream of a global empire and world government is completely evil. The Jewish prophets have the opinion that these empires, considering themselves responsible for bringing peace and prosperity to the world, are actually murderous entities. The wars fought for the formation of such empires destroy the heritage and traditions of the land they conquer.

Thus, Dr Hazony said that looking at these 2000 years of Christian history, it has been a ‘see-saw’ struggle within Christianity. There has been a constant struggle between the Holy Christian Roman Empire, which sought to take over the whole world and bring peace and salvation to all mankind by imposing Christian imperialism. On the other hand, Christian nationalism, inspired by the Jewish Bible, supported the nations to free themselves from the universal empire. The examples of nations connecting themselves with the idea of national freedom were Poland, Hungary, Czech Republic, France, England, Netherlands and later even in Italy.

The Conservatives believed in living according to their own traditions and the understanding of God in an independent way. The ‘see-saw’ struggle came to a conclusion in the 1500s when many Protestants came out in support of Jewish nationalism. This vision developed in the 1500s, the nations’ drive to live independently to pursue their own form of independence continued till the 20th century when the western empires started tilting towards the direction of recognizing national independence.

Dr Hazony stated that the idea of nationalism before the second World War had a generous approach, the idea of independence was progressive and the viewpoint was towards a gracious and free nation. The world changed post Second World War. The Marxist and Liberal academics in the universities posited Hitler and the genocide of Jews as an example of national independence and how that led to destruction of the world. It was an aggressive move by the universities against nationalism. This revived theory of ‘international liberalism’ led to the formation of the European Union (EU), a single law for the whole world and new world order and globalism. Amongst the academic institutions at that period of time, 95% of the academic establishments and universities were either liberal, universalist or marxist globalists. These views and ideas took over the universities and increased exponentially.

With the fall of the Berlin wall in 1989, it was the end of struggle between the western liberal nations and the communist nations and the liberal nations had emerged triumphant. In 1990, George Bush came to power in America, declaring a global ‘new world order’. The ‘new world order’ would replace the law of the jungle into a universal rule of law, that is, one law around the globe. Dr Hazony explained how shocking it was that the fight for independent nations changed into a collection of the whole world under a single law, which in today’s world is called as globalism or liberal internationalism.

Dr Hazony mentioned that until Brexit and the introduction of Donald Trump to the world, the West was overtaken by the fantasy and utopian vision that it had defeated all its enemies and under a single umbrella of law, it could bring peace and prosperity to the entire world. This worldview ended the Jewish Biblical vision of independent nations and the world had circled back to the Roman Empire. When the EU was created in 1992, people were caught up in euphoria, the goal was changed to eliminating all borders and no warfare in Europe, which was a utopian vision. The decision of having one currency affected the economic independence of European countries.

2016 was the year of debate between the liberal internationalists (or the utopians) and conservative nationalists (or realistic people) to be able to maintain their independent national approach and pursue their own interests and philosophy. But in 2020, there were major changes that took place in the liberal institutional structure in Europe and America as they were going under a ‘cultural revolution’. The change was visible in western media like the New York Times and in universities like Princeton.

Dr Hazony ended his lecture by saying that there is a long way to go and we cannot keep on believing in the existence of the same liberal ideology that was formed after the second World War, the ideology has evolved into a new woke narrative of Marxism and it is much different from the original liberal ideology, and the resistance is national conservatism.

Prof Shri Prakash Singh commented on the lecture by citing the example of C Rajagopalachari and stated that he was the first openly declared conservative of the country and greatest opponent of Marxism. He initiated reforms against casteism in 1917 in colonial India and in 1960s against the license permit quota system.

Concluding remarks of the lecture were given by Dr Ram Madhav, President, India Foundation. He said that Dr Hazony was one of the key authorities on core conservative thought. He said nations are not just ‘imagined communities’ but are ‘organically evolved communities’. He spoke about evolving an Indian conservative thought presenting our own ideas and thoughts of nations. A coherent conservative school of ideological thought has been lost and we should develop our own discourse and create literature that could match the idiom that today’s generation would understand. He said that the idea of Nationalism has been turned into a pejorative after the second World War, thus there is a need to develop a new school of thought with a contemporary outlook.

Indic Curriculum on Political Science

India Foundation, in collaboration with Rishihood University, organized a roundtable discussion on “Indic Curriculum on Political Science” at the India Habitat Centre, New Delhi, on July 25, 2023. The session was chaired and moderated by Shri Shobhit Mathur, Vice Chancellor, Rishihood University. The initial and closing remarks were delivered by Dr. Ram Madhav, President, India Foundation. A special address was delivered by Dr. Mahesh Chandra Sharma, Former Member of Parliament, Rajya Sabha. The discussion touched upon various dimensions of the current status of political science curricula in higher education, and explored the possibilities of constructing an academic pedagogy which would revolve around Pt. Deendayal Upadhyay’s idea of ‘Integral Humanism’. The discussants also laid emphasis on tailoring such curriculum to the needs and employability of students opting for it, so as to ensure that they are able to build a strong foundation in the domain of political science and can lay claim to good academic credentials.

Public Lecture on “The Virtue of Nationalism”

The Hyderabad Chapter of Forum for Nationalist Thinkers, in association with India Foundation organized a public lecture on “The Virtue of Nationalism” on July 25, 2023, at Taj Deccan, Hyderabad. The lecture was delivered by Dr. Yoram Hazony, Israeli philosopher and Chairman, Edmund Burke Foundation. The theme of the lecture was based on Dr. Hazony’s book on nationalism published in 2018. The session was presided by Shri N. Ramchander Rao, Former Member of Legislative Council, Telangana. The Guest of Honour for the session was Dr. K. Aravinda Rao, IPS (Retd.), former Director-General of Police, Andhra Pradesh. The public lecture was attended by senior scholars, social leaders, public intellectuals, and other eminent dignitaries of Hyderabad.

Symposium on India’s Nationalist Traditions

India Foundation organized a Symposium on ‘India’s Nationalist Traditions’ on July 22-23, 2023, in Udaipur, Rajasthan. The Keynote Address for the symposium was delivered by Hon’ble Minister of External Affairs of India, Dr. S. Jaishankar. The Hon’ble Minister highlighted the global appeal of Indian traditions of cultural nationalism and pluralism. The Introductory and Closing Remarks were delivered by Mananiya Dattatreya Hosabale, Sarkaryavah, Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh. Ma. Dattatreya Ji also presided over all the sessions of the symposium, and contributed significantly through his deep insights and valuable interventions. The symposium was chaired by Shri Swapan Dasgupta, Former Member of Parliament, Rajya Sabha, and Member, Governing Council, India Foundation. The sessions were also moderated by Dr. Ram Madhav, President, India Foundation. The Symposium witnessed an active dialogue among 27 eminent personalities, including academicians, thinkers, ideologues, and young scholars.  The symposium served as a crucial platform to brainstorm over the evolution and trajectory of Indian nationalism, and to deliberate on the futuristic visions that it can provide for both the Indian nation and the world. As a part of the initiative to positively engage with the global intellectual frameworks of nationalism, the symposium also had the active participation of Dr. Yoram Hazony, Israeli philosopher and Chairman, Edmund Burke Foundation, and Mr. Walter Russell Mead, Ravenel B. Curry III Distinguished Fellow in Strategy and Statesmanship, Hudson Institute.

Round Table on Global Trade and Investment

 

A closed door round table discussion was organised on July 18, 2023 (Tuesday) at the India Foundation Office. The primary focus of discussion was on global trade and investment, current trends and future possibilities. The round table was addressed by Mr. Didier Darcet, Co-founder, Gavekal Intelligence Software and was moderated by Mr. Shaurya Doval, Member, Governing Council India Foundation. Eminent economy and policy aficionados working within the field participated in the event and deliberated on the feasibility of numerous strategies that can be applied for the benefit of Indian markets on the global stage.

Lunch Interaction with H.E Dr. Mohammad Bin Abdulkarim Al-Issa

India Foundation organized a Lunch Interaction with H.E Dr. Mohammad bin-Abdulkarim Al-Issa, Hon. Secretary General, Muslim World League on Sunday, July 16, 2023 at The Leela Palace, New Delhi. Dr. Ram Madhav, President, India Foundation and Vice Admiral Shekhar Sinha, Chairman, Board of Trustees, India Foundation were present at the gathering. The lunch was attended by an eminent group of dignitaries.

 

 

 

 

 

 

In his remarks, H. E. Dr. Al Issa expressed his delight at the completion of a successful visit to India and his deep appreciation for the political, religious, and cultural meetings he held during the course of his visit. He spoke about the need of diverse nations and cultures to co-exist while maintaining a peaceful and healthy competition that serves the needs of all parties involved. He highlighted that there is both good and evil in the world but it is important that we bring the positives to light.

Dr. Al Issa emphasised on peace, importance and understanding of the constitution. He unequivocally rejected terrorism and extremism. His sentiment of a global brotherhood resonates well with the current G20 motto of ‘Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam’

E. Dr. Al Issa interacted with the audience informally and shared his thoughts over lunch.

Indo-Japan Business Development Dialogue 2022-2023

India Foundation and the Kajima Institute of International Peace (KIIP), Tokyo, Japan jointly organised the Indo-Japan Business Development Dialogue, a year-long initiative between India Foundation, New Delhi, and the Kajima Institute of International Peace (KIIP), Tokyo, on the theme “The Future of India- Japan Business Development/ Strengthening of Trade Ties”. Eminent businessmen, academicians, and former diplomats from Japan & India participated in all 12 editions. From India, the dialogue was addressed by Ms Deepa Gopalan Wadhwa, Indian Foreign Service (Retired) Former Ambassador to Sweden, Latvia, Qatar, Japan and the Marshall Islands. Mr Ritesh Sharma, an MBA graduate from IIM Lucknow, Mr Manoj Kohli, Country Head, SoftBank, India, Mr Ajay Sethi, Managing Partner of ASA & Associates LLP (ASA), India, Mr Bharat Joshi, Co-chair CII Japan, Mr Bharat Kaushal, Managing Director, Hitachi India Pvt. Ltd, and Dr Srabani Roy Choudhary, Professor, Jawaharlal Nehru University, Delhi, India.

From Japan, the dialogue was addressed by Mr Naotaka Nishiyama, President of Tech Japan, Dr Katsuo Matsumoto, Head, of Infrastructure Engineering Department, Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), Dr Mai Fujita, Director, Southeast Asia Studies Group II, Area Studies Center, Institute of Developing Economies, Japan External Trade Organization, Dr Harukata Takenaka, Professor at the National Graduate Institute for Policy Studies, and Mr Hiroki Sekine of JBIC, a Government-sponsored export credit agency.

In a year-long series of discussions, experts from both India and Japan have discussed and deliberated on how India-Japan relationship should look like, what the potential is, where we are missing the mark and what is the way ahead. Here’s an overview.

India and Japan have a prominent shared history. The exports from India to Japan have ranged from 3.8 billion USD to 4.9 billion since 2016 and were not heavily impacted during the COVID-19 crisis. Similarly, the imports to India from Japan weren’t much affected and have ranged between 9.8 billion USD to over 12.8 billion dollars.

Japan has contributed through FDIs to India for a long time, since 2014 Japanese FDI has gone up to 4.3 billion USD in Indian markets. This includes companies like Nippon Steel, Fuji Electric, and Uniqlo in the manufacturing and retail sector, names like SMBC, Jera, NEC, and NTT

Communications in Services and Soft Bank, GMO, ORIX, Toyota Tshusho in the investment sector. It is paramount to mention that the total outbound FDI from Japan has been USD 2.4 Trillion between 1995 and 2021. North America and Europe have accounted for about 2/3rd of it with approximately USD 700 billion each.

It has been suggested that India continues offering on-the-ground structural support to emerge as a long-term preferred investment destination for Japanese capital. Companies in Japan also need to continue with prudent investing philosophy and market-driven post-investment strategies. In the future, the proactive resolution and anticipation of likely challenges in capital incentive sectors are very important. The mandatory listings in infrastructure and NBFCs could be a prevention mechanism.

Japan is facing challenges, especially in terms of the usage of funds in development, marketing, recruitment, and overseas expansion, and the shortage of IT manpower. To engage highly skilled Indian talents in Japan, Tech Japan is in collaboration with IIT Madras, IIT Bombay, IIT Kharagpur, Kanpur, IIT Roorkee, IIT Hyderabad, IIM Bangalore, IIM Ahmedabad, and IISC Bangalore. The language barrier between India and Japan came out as a major concern.

Japan is the 12th largest trade partner for India and India is the 18th largest trade partner for Japan. This shows despite all friendships, partnerships, and good relationships, our trade ties are not up to the mark.

India is at a bright spot in the world, as it is growing at 6- 7%, and is expected to grow by another 6-7% next year, where the entire world is in recession. So, this is the right time for Japan to also look at India for a higher degree of trade and investment, especially in sectors like infrastructure, manufacturing, software, start-ups, pharmacy, healthcare, defence, & tourism.

In the past decade, the relationship between India and Japan has deepened the diplomatic, military, economic, and cultural ties. The scope of cooperation has expanded. India has started spending more on transportation, communication, health care and other areas, which shows that the size of the wallet has dramatically increased in a manner that the generations are able to spend much more on interesting things than just necessary living. This proves that consumption is high in India. Japan has an ageing population and the childbirth rate is controlled. So, Japan’s biggest challenge today is to balance the population. Older people are one challenge, but the bigger challenge is much of the products are directed at children or other consuming markets.

India’s new foreign trade policy which has been unveiled in 2023 would be organic in nature and would continue to look towards enhancing India’s position as a country where business would come.

We see huge engagement projects initiated by Japan especially with respect to the Bay of Bengal initiative and linkages between the northeast India & Bangladesh. There has been a lot of focus on infrastructure development especially after 2018, in which JICA is predominantly working. We also have the Bamboo initiative that has happened, which is a new kind of initiative. India & Japan are keen on the technology transfer and infrastructure development.  Both the countries should further scale up the existing economic ties, enhance the economic development projects, upgrade Hi-tech verticals, boost manufacturing sector, automobile and electronic industry.

Syama Prasad Mookerjee Lecture

India Foundation organized Syama Prasad Mookerjee Lecture on July 06, 2023, to commemorate the 122nd birth anniversary of Dr. Syama Prasad Mookerjee. The lecture was held on the theme “Hindutva’s Tryst with Politics: Legacy of Dr Syama Prasad Mookerjee”. Ma. Dattatreya Hosabale, Sarkaryavah, Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), delivered the keynote address in the session, which was attended by senior scholars, politicians, academicians, journalists, former bureaucrats and other dignitaries based in New Delhi. In his keynote address, Ma. Dattatreya Ji highlighted how Dr. Syama Prasad Mookerjee gave shape to the political dimension of the Hindutva worldview and emerged as a formidable leader of Hindutva politics. He also discussed the need for a studied approach to understand Dr. Mookerjee’s important contributions as an educationist.

(Glimpses of the lecture are available here.)

Peace, Prosperity and Partnership for a Resilient Future in the Indian Ocean Region

The Indian Ocean, home to nearly 3 billion people, has regained its historical prominence. It now constitutes the main axle of gravity in this emerging multi-polar world. It is essential for countries around the Indian Ocean Region, all of us, irrespective of our varying sizes, to partner, work together, and combine our efforts, strive to foster peace, and lead the world into a new era of stability and prosperity.

In this post-covid era and on-going Russia-Ukraine war, all long-held assumptions have been disturbed. The international context is furthermore compounded by the furtherance of national interests and the emergence of new alliances. All of us have this common responsibility to design ways and means to overcome those challenges, develop resilience and create new opportunities.

Mauritius very early realised that to expand its political and economic space, it should embrace a high dose of pragmatism. True to our multi-ethnic and deep respect for diversity, we espouse a high degree of openness in terms of our attitude and culture, our national and foreign policy; and our economic strategy and development model. Our belonging to the Commonwealth and to the Francophone Organisation also helped Mauritius to establish close relations with newly independent Anglophone and Francophone States. In the Cold War divide, we fully supported the concept of the Indian Ocean as a Zone of Peace.

Mauritius also stepped into the realm of international relations as a small a Developing States (SIDS) to voice our specificities on social, economic and environmental challenges particularly climate change. Yet, being a small country, we cannot write history and are resigned to accept the world as it is. At the dawn of its Independence, Mauritius had its territory dismembered. The Chagos Archipelago was detached by the then colonial power in clear violation of international law and the UN General Assembly Declaration.

We have persistently maintained that in so doing our decolonisation remained incomplete and we have been fighting for full sovereignty over the Chagos Archipelago.

We have had the unflinching support of a large majority of states, including the African Continent, Bangladesh and India among others all throughout. Starting from the Advisory Opinion of the International Court of Justice in 2019. To the recent judgments delivered by the Special Chamber of the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea in April. We pray for continued support from all of you so that at the earliest Mauritius can have full and effective sovereignty over the Chagos Archipelago.

At a very early stage, Mauritius also expressed its commitment in furthering regional cooperation as an instrument for peace, progress and prosperity. We developed special relations with countries of the region. India given our shared People-to-People history ever since the establishment of diplomatic relations, as early as 1948, and up till now, has remained a strategic partner accompanying Mauritius in its development process.

The creation of the Indian Ocean Commission (IOC) in 1982, bringing together five Member States of the South West Indian Ocean Namely: 1. the Comoros, 2. France on behalf of Reunion Island 3. Madagascar, 4. Mauritius and 5. Seychelles, bears testimony to this endeavour.

This commission is the only regional organization in Africa composed exclusively of islands. It defends the specificities of its Member States on the continental and international scenes, while also cooperating in projects covering a wide range of sectors namely: 1. preservation of ecosystems, 2. sustainable management of natural resources, 3. renewable energy and 4. maritime safety.

The Indian Ocean Commission has strengthened and diversified its partnerships since 2016 and welcomed observer members including: 1. China, 2. India 3. Japan 4. the European Union, 5. The “Organisation Internationale de Iq Francophonie”, and 6. the United Nations.

This has paved the way for the development of a mutually beneficial relationship in the sphere of regional cooperation and relating particularly to maritime security. In parallel, the Indian Ocean Rim Association (IORA) was created in 1997 to strengthen the ties between Member States whose shores are washed by the vast expanse of the Indian Ocean. Bringing together countries from contours of Asia to the shores of Africa and the Middle East, and stretching from its multitude of Islands to Australia.

It may be recalled that the vision for countries linked to the Indian Ocean to become a single platform originated during a visit by late President Nelson Mandela to India in 1995, where he said: “The natural urge of the facts of history and geography…should broaden itself to include the concept of an Indian Ocean Rim for socio-economic cooperation and other peaceful endeavours.

Today, the IORA is a dynamic organisation of 23 Member States and 10 Dialogue Partners, with an ever-growing momentum for mutually beneficial regional cooperation through a: (i). consensus-based, (ii). Evolutionary and (iii). non-intrusive approach.

Security is at the core of peace and prosperity. Piracy, territorial disputes, terrorism and illicit arms; drugs and human trafficking; illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing; oil spills and marine pollution…. just to mention a few…represent a major threat to maritime security and pose significant governance challenges for policymakers of the region. It is, therefore, essential that we deepen our mutual cooperation and strengthen our ability and ensure safety and stability in the India Ocean. In that regard, the enhancement of Maritime Domain Awareness is an important aspect. The initiative by India in 2018 to set up the Information Fusion Centre – Indian Ocean Region should also be applauded.

We also welcome the recent signing of the MoU between the Centre and the Indian Ocean Commission led Architecture for Maritime Security and its Regional Coordination Operation Centre in Seychelles. These are concrete examples which we need to emulate given that individually we cannot effectively address such threats in a sustainable manner.

The global economy remains continuously threatened by uncertainties compounded by the present ongoing war. We have been witnessing significant disruptions in trade and food supplies; and surge in fuel price. These are contributing to greater financial stress, increased debt levels, high inflation and significant tightening in global financing. We all apprehend prolonged and intensified hostilities. These are real and legitimate cause of concern. It is thus imperative that we explore alternative solutions which would facilitate smoother movement of goods and people, boost tourism, develop better infrastructure, protect the environment and improve disaster response, develop the Blue Economy among others.

To improve maritime connectivity, reflections are being undertaken by Mauritius on how to set up feeder maritime services. However, the costs are prohibitive. We should strive to maintain a peaceful environment within the Indian ocean region and beyond. Peace is essential. Without peace, there is no prosperity. But prosperity also demands that we look beyond our diverse national ambitions. No country, big or small, has the ability to build a resilient future on its own. Thus, we should all partner. We need collective actions among regional organizations, governments, the private sector and civil society. We should all endeavour to build trust, identify our common objectives and collectively move towards our set goals with the aim of boosting prosperity. Let us start by working on regional projects which have the potential to yield positive outcomes for the betterment of our people.

Author Brief Bio: His Excellency Mr. Prithvirajsing ROOPUN, G.C.S.K., is the Hon’ble President of the Mauritius.

Note: This article is based on the Text of the Speech delivered by H.E. Mr. Prithvirajsing ROOPUN, G.C.S.K., the Hon’ble President of the Mauritius, in the Inaugural Session at the 6th Indian Ocean Conference 2023 in Dhaka on 12 May 2023

Collaborate for a Future of Enduring Peace and Shared Prosperity in the Indian Ocean Region

A resilient and sustainable future is a choice that requires proactive measures that promotes transformation. It involves adaptive management, learning, innovation, and the leadership to manage risks and uncertainty.

We must increase our engagements and unify our collective efforts to ensure peace in the region. A single nation cannot ensure the security and resilience of the region surrounding the vast Indian Ocean. We must accept the collective responsibility for ensuring regional stability by strengthening our regional alliances.

We must leverage cooperation to generate sustained economic development in order to assure the security and prosperity of our region’s citizens and beyond.

The Indian Ocean Region is home to some of the world’s fastest-growing civilizations. It serves as a hub for trade with the Middle East, Africa, East Asia, Europe, and the Americas. It is the responsibility, therefore, of all the nations to ensure peace, economic prosperity, environmental protection, and international rules in the region.

Maldives President Ibrahim Mohamed Solih has made the security of the Indian Ocean a top priority. We are mindful of obstacles that threaten stable socioeconomic progress in the Indian Ocean, including non-traditional security threats such as terrorism, human trafficking, irregular migration, drug smuggling, and illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing.

Degradation of ocean health, illegal exploitation of marine resources, and climate change are additional concerns in the region of the Indian Ocean. Small, low-lying island nations, such as the Maldives, are particularly vulnerable to climate pressures. The nations of the Indian Ocean are the most vulnerable, as a number of their populations reside in low-lying coastal settlements.

We must establish partnerships based on mutual respect and trust. This is essential for resolving outstanding issues and promoting prosperity, sustainability, and stability in the Indian Ocean region through a rules-based approach.

We should focus on development, actively engage in practical cooperation in business and trade, energy, science, and technology and exert considerable effort to better the lives of the populace.

Our societies are becoming increasingly interconnected and inter-dependent, evolving as a community with a common future. The economic turmoil created by the COVID-19 pandemic for instance has revealed numerous vulnerabilities in the global supply chain and starkly reminded us of the important need to build and harmonize our international partnerships to guarantee undisrupted supply chains.

As a country totally reliant on imports from food to fuel, the Maldives faced several challenges with the closure of borders during the pandemic. We had the good fortune of enjoying close relations with all our bilateral partners, especially with our close neighbours in the Indian Ocean and our challenges were met with their prompt assistance.

Numerous solutions to the problems confronting the planet and humanity are already known. In reality, we cannot effectively address any of these challenges if we lack effective institutions that can regulate and monitor progress in all these domains. We must be mindful to recognize our deficiencies in this regard.

The Maldives is committed to ensuring sustainable fishing practices and has joined the Indian Ocean Rim Association in 2019. IORA has been successful in uniting nations with a shared vision for the Indian Ocean, and the Maldives will stand firm in promoting the region’s sustained growth and balanced development as a member of IORA.

The Maldives is also an active member of the Colombo Security Conclave. With its focus on ensuring maritime safety and security in the Indian Ocean, terrorism and radicalisation, cyber security and humanitarian aid and disaster relief, the conclave has established frameworks for cooperation, while also strengthening cooperation within the countries.

Faced with these global challenges, Maldives will uphold the spirit of partnership, inclusiveness, openness, and intensify dialogue to increase mutual trust and coordination and work together to establish a prosperous and peaceful future for the region.

To ensure a healthy and prosperous future for all, we must increase our engagements and unify our collective efforts through greater leadership. Let us remain steadfast in our commitments to regional peace and prosperity, uphold the spirit of partnership, inclusiveness, and transparency, and collaborate for a future of enduring peace and shared prosperity.

Author Brief Bio: His Excellency Faisal Naseem is the Vice President of the Republic of Maldives.

Note: This article is based on the Text of the Speech delivered by H.E. Faisal Naseem, Vice President of the Republic of Maldives, in the Inaugural Session at the 6th Indian Ocean Conference 2023 in Dhaka on 12 May 2023.

Fostering Partnerships and Cooperation in the Indian Ocean Region

Our oceans and seas account for 90% of world trade and 60% of oil transportation. The real value of global maritime trade has remarkably tripled in the past 15 years. Oceans offer excellent opportunities in supporting sustainable development in countries the world over. Yet much of the potential still remains untapped.

The Indian Ocean Region has significant economic, political, and strategic implications in the Asia-Pacific and African regions. It shares 64% of global population and 60% of global GDP.

Despite its potential, the region faces many challenges. The countries in the Indian Ocean region, therefore, need to foster partnerships and cooperation for ensuring peace, and prosperity for all.

Our Father of the Nation Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman underscored optimum utilization of Bangladesh’s maritime resources for its development, growth and stability. A visionary leader, he enacted the “Territorial Waters and Maritime Zones Act, 1974”, to set the limit of Bangladesh’s ‘Maritime Zones’; to enable conduct of different activities within the limit; and also, to facilitate exploration of sea resources.

Notably, this Act came into force eight years prior to the “United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, 1982”, at a time, when the global community had limited understanding of the matter.

The theme of the Conference – “Peace, Partnership and Prosperity: Towards a resilient future” – is very appropriate and timely. There is an intricate relation among the three to ensure a resilient future.

The discussion on Peace, Prosperity and Partnership for a Resilient Future in the Indian Ocean Region becomes all the more relevant in light of the recent Covid-19 pandemic, and the ongoing Russia-Ukraine conflict, and consequent sanctions and counter-sanctions. These have posed unprecedented challenges for all nations world over.

Global recession, food, energy, and fertilizer crises have resulted in unbearable living conditions for all people of the world. The Indian Ocean region has also been facing challenges such as climate change, maritime security, terrorism, and natural disasters. To overcome them, the countries in the region must come together to build partnership, and put collective efforts to promote peace and prosperity, for a brighter region.

In the context of the post-Covid world and the Russia-Ukraine war, a resolution titled “International Year of Dialogue as a Guarantee of Peace, 2023” was adopted unanimously at the UNGA in December 2022.

In that resolution, the historic quote of the Father of the Nation Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman from his 1974 UN speech, which is also the foreign policy dictum of Bangladesh, was inserted in the 14th paragraph of the resolution. It reads: “Recognizing the importance of combating poverty, hunger, disease, illiteracy, and unemployment, and emphasizing that friendship to all and malice towards none, in the spirit of constructive cooperation, dialogue, and mutual understanding, will help to achieve these objectives.”

It is so relevant for us in the Indian Ocean region as we endeavor to formulate actions for a resilient future. In line with the quote of Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujib, we need effective ‘partnership’ in the form of meaningful cooperation, dialogue and mutual understanding to achieve our shared objectives of ensuring peace and prosperity in the region.

Father of the Nation Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman in his historic speech also said, “Peace is an imperative for the survival of mankind; it represents the deepest aspirations of men and women throughout the world.” In that speech, he particularly emphasized on keeping the Indian Ocean as a peaceful area.

In his pursuit of world peace and human rights, Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was awarded the Joliot-Curie Medal of Peace on 23 May, 1973. Following Bangabandhu’s philosophy, Bangladesh became an ardent advocate for world peace. In 1997 at the United Nations General Assembly, Bangladesh tabled a resolution on “Culture of Peace” which was unanimously adopted.

Subsequently, the United Nations declared the year 2000 as the “International Year of Culture of Peace,” and designated the years 2001-2010 as the “Culture of Peace and the Decade of Non-violence.”

Bangladesh views the “Culture of Peace” as an essential element that will reinforce all aspects of peace. It is why Bangladesh is committed to UN’s global peacekeeping and peace-building endeavors. Currently Bangladeshi troops’ contribution to United Nations Peacekeeping is among the highest in the world.

Despite many challenges, Bangladesh provided temporary shelter to more than 1.1 million Forcibly Displaced Myanmar Nationals. This gesture avoided a major humanitarian catastrophe in the region. Now, we seek active support of the global community to repatriate the Rohingya people to their homeland in a safe and sustainable manner.

Bangladesh believes in the challenges, traditional and non-traditional, that the Indian Ocean region is facing. Bangladesh remains committed to playing our role for peace in the region, and expect all other countries to do the same to ensure a resilient future.

Bangladesh, as a littoral state, has been a hub of maritime activities for centuries. It is active in many regional platforms. Bangladesh is the current Chair of the Indian Ocean Rim Association. It is also the current President of the Council of the International Seabed Authority.

Over the last decade, Bangladesh made significant strides in socio-economic growth and social justice. Bangladesh is now the 35th largest economy in the world. Extreme poverty rate has gone down to 5.6% in recent years, and our per capita income has tripled to 2824 USD within a decade. Bangladesh has met all of the necessary criteria for graduating from the Least Developed Country (LDC) category to a developing country in 2026.

We aspire to build ‘Smart Bangladesh” with robust physical infrastructure to support a thriving economy. Last year, we inaugurated the self-funded ‘Padma Multi-purpose Bridge”. Recently we inaugurated the first-ever Metro Rail service in our capital. We shall soon complete the Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman Tunnel, a 3.2-kilometer under-river tunnel in Chattogram, the first of its kind in South Asia.

Our aspiration is to transform Bangladesh into a knowledge-based, modern, developed country, the ‘Sonar Bangla’ by 2041, and to build a prosperous and climate-resilient delta by 2100. Our strategy for achieving these goals involves promoting sustainable economic growth and generating opportunities for all.

Given its geographical position, the Indian Ocean holds significant importance for not only Bangladesh, but for all the countries in the region. We have recently formulated our Indo-Pacific Outlook.

In similar spirit, I would like to underscore six priority areas as follows:

 

  1. Countries in the Indian Ocean Region should foster “Maritime Diplomacy” for their development, thereby ensuring a prosperous future.
  2. Climate vulnerability of many countries in the region calls for the need to enhance cooperation to reduce the impact of natural disasters.
  3. Strengthen mutual trust and respect among the countries for building strong partnerships to ensure stability for a resilient future in the Indian Ocean.
  4. Strengthen existing mechanisms on maritime safety and security in the Indian Ocean, including response to emergencies at sea, conduct of search and rescue, uphold the exercise of freedom of navigation and over flight, in accordance with international law.
  5. Promote ‘culture of peace’ and people centric development in the region. Women, half of the global population, should get due attention, for building peaceful, just and inclusive societies in the region.
  6. Need to promote open, transparent, rules-based multilateral systems that facilitate equitable and sustainable development in the region and beyond through inclusive economic growth.

Author Brief Bio: Her Excellency Sheikh Hasina is the Hon’ble Prime Minister of Bangladesh.

Note: This article is based on the Text of the Speech delivered by H.E. Sheikh Hasina, Hon’ble Prime Minister of Bangladesh, in the Inaugural Session at the 6th Indian Ocean Conference 2023 in Dhaka on 12 May 2023.

Addressing the needs of the Indian Ocean Region

Bangladesh released its Indo-Pacific Outlook on 24 April 2023. By doing so, Bangladesh joined a number of countries ranging from ASEAN and East Asia to Europe and North America in articulating its thinking on this important subject. Indo-Pacific is a reality and becoming more so with each passing day. It is a statement of our contemporary globalization and an underlining that we are getting past the framework of 1945. There are obviously nations who have a vested interest in perpetuating the past. As indeed they have in larger international relations, including the structure of the United Nations. But time does not stand still for anyone; change has to be recognized. And I am truly glad that Bangladesh has joined the company of those who have done so.

The four Guiding Principles and the fifteen Objectives of Bangladesh’s outlook and its respect for the 1982 UN Convention on the Law of the Seas (UNCLOS) needs to be highlighted. It is essential for the credibility of the global order that such foundational regimes are respected and scrupulously observed by all signatories. The views of Bangladesh are particularly noteworthy because of its standing as a progressive and successful developing economy that is making its fullest contribution to regional growth and prosperity.

Because the world is understandably seized of the larger domain of the Indo-Pacific, we should not underplay the issues and challenges of one of its core constituents – the nations of the Indian Ocean. Our historical experience is somewhat different than those of the Pacific, even if we are joined at the hip. There are distinct issues that arise from regional identities, colonial experiences and geo-political relationships. Many nations of the Indian Ocean still address developmental challenges that may no longer be relevant in the Pacific. So, even while impressing the essential coherence of the Indo-Pacific, I would urge that we also focus determinedly on the Indian Ocean nations and their challenges.

Within the Indian Ocean, we must recognize that there are distinct regions and ecosystems. The Bay of Bengal is a very good example. The countries in this geography have their particular aspirations and agenda, as well as their respective pathways towards progress. We are members of the BIMSTEC, an organization that is increasingly coming into its own. Amongst ourselves, we are very cognizant of the challenges, we face in governance, modernization and security. And we are confident of dealing with them through deeper cooperation and shared efforts. It is by nurturing such building blocks that we will make the Indian Ocean – indeed the Indo-Pacific – stronger and more resilient.

The requirement of simultaneously addressing the needs of the Indo-Pacific, the Indian Ocean and its constituent regions is today the task before us. These are not alternatives but actually self-supporting activities. Naturally, there are aspects of specificity; but equally, there are broad principles that apply to all. For example, the importance of adhering to law, observing norms and respecting rules is a natural convergence point. It is not possible to build a stable international order without these pre-requisites. This is especially so in a continent that has seen so much growth and so much change. When nations disregard their legal obligations or violate long-standing agreements, as we have seen, the damage to trust and confidence is immense. It is therefore essential that all of us take the long view of our cooperation, rather than a tactical one of our interests.

A significant shared concern through the Indian Ocean is that of unsustainable debt generated by unviable projects. There are lessons from the last two decades that we ignore at our peril. If we encourage opaque lending practices, exorbitant ventures and price points that are unrelated to the market, these are bound to bite us back, sooner rather than later. Especially so when sovereign guarantees have been proffered, not always with due diligence. Many of us in the region are today confronting the consequences of our past choices. This is time to reflect and reform, not one to repeat and reiterate.

Connectivity is a particularly crucial issue for all of us. This is because the era of imperialism disrupted the natural linkages of the continent and created regional silos to serve its own ends. In many cases, the hinterland was disadvantaged to the benefit of the coastal areas. Building back in the post-colonial era is a long, painful and arduous task. It is still very much work in progress. How to restore, indeed enhance flows between distinct regions is today of the utmost priority. For a nation like India, this means a land-connect to South East Asia. And a multi-modal one to the Gulf and beyond. Central Asia offers its own distinct challenges due to obstacles in between. Collectively, the more we work on facilitating smooth and effective connectivity, the better off we all are. And obviously, we need to respect sovereignty and territorial integrity while doing so. Let me therefore underline that from India’s perspective, efficient and effective connectivity to ASEAN in particular will be a game-changer. We accord this the utmost priority.

As nations of the Indian Ocean, we are united in our interest in the maritime sphere. Here too, there is much that we who inhabit this ocean must reflect on. The era where maritime spaces would be secured by others is now behind us. With each passing day, this is increasingly our shared responsibility. We must discharge that, sharply aware that global good should not be sacrificed at the altar of any national dominance. To do so, we must put in place the bilateral, plurilateral and regional tools and mechanisms to achieve our ends. It would mean exchanging information on white shipping, cooperating on coastal surveillance or collaborating on maritime domain awareness. Diplomacy cannot rest content merely by articulating positions; it equally needs practical action to back it up.

There are some global challenges that also merit regional considerations. Chief among them are climate action and counter-terrorism. The universality of these concerns is by now well recognized. It is essential that our conversations aim to encourage common positions. We must also be conscious of the threats to social fabric posed by extremism and fundamentalism taking advantage of democratic openness. The costs of not doing so are also starkly apparent to all of us today.

Nations of the Indian Ocean are among those who lead the rise of Asia and the re-emergence of Africa. They have the responsibility today of shaping the narrative, shaping it about values, practices and correctness. It is essential that their culture, history and traditions are presented to the world. If we are to compare the relative weight of littorals, that of the Indian Ocean still has to play catch-up. Our challenge, indeed our responsibility, is to hasten that process.

India is committed to the well-being and progress of all nations of the Indian Ocean. We have dedicated bodies like the Indian Ocean Rim Association or the Indian Ocean Naval Symposium, with their specific mandates. We expand on that belief through the Neighbourhood First policy, the SAGAR outlook and our approach to the extended neighbourhood. Beyond that, we believe that a seamless transition into an Indo-Pacific is to our collective advantage.

Author Brief Bio: Dr. S. Jaishankar is the External Affairs Minister, Government of India.

Note: This article is based on the Text of the Speech delivered by Dr. S. Jaishankar, External Affairs Minister, Government of India, in the Inaugural Session at the 6th Indian Ocean Conference 2023 in Dhaka on 12 May 2023.

Singapore’s interest in the Indian Ocean

Over the last three thousand years, the Indian Ocean has been an essential conduit for trade, culture, religion, knowledge, language, and geostrategic influence. In particular, South Asian influences in heritage, language, and religion, borne across the waves of the Indian Ocean, are evident in Southeast Asia. Even today, Sanskrit remains a legacy in our languages, and influences of Buddhism, Hinduism, and Islam remain in our belief systems.

The Indian Ocean region holds tremendous geopolitical, economic, and strategic importance. Extending from the eastern coast of Africa to the western coast of Australia, the Indian Ocean accounts for one-fifth of the water on the Earth’s surface. A significant portion of global maritime traffic flows through the Indian Ocean from Asia’s industrialised nations to the rest of the world. More than 70% of the world’s oil shipments pass through the Indian Ocean, as does 50% of container traffic. There is no question that the Indian Ocean is of strategic importance for all of us.

Global challenges

The COVID-19 pandemic impacted countries around the world, including those in the Indian Ocean region. We all faced disruptions to our economies, supply chains, connectivity networks, border management, regional security, critical health infrastructure and tourism, just to name a few. We saw how international connectivity is a double-edged sword – while it enhanced international trade, it can also disable trade links. But the crisis also provided an opportunity for countries to work together in both traditional and non-traditional areas, relook existing institutions and regional mechanisms, and revamp them in order to better serve today’s needs. It reminds us even more how important it is to work together, uphold multilateral trading systems and resist protectionist policies.

Amidst the background of other international crises such as the Russia-Ukraine war, there have been major disruptions to trade and critical supply chains, and deep uncertainty has arisen about the future of multilateral institutions. As the world’s major powers become increasingly assertive of their own interests, the hitherto hard-won consensus on international rules and norms is breaking down before our very eyes.

Impact of Climate Change

The countries in the Indian Ocean region are also grappling with the existential challenge of climate change. The Sixth Assessment Report or AR6 of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change recently concluded “with very high confidence” that the Indian Ocean’s surface has warmed faster than the global average. This presents a host of challenges for the Indian Ocean states, including the intensification of monsoon rains, marine biodiversity loss and sea-level rise.

In particular, rising sea-levels have serious cascading effects on many other areas, such as the economy, livelihoods, health and well-being, as well as food and water security. As a low-lying state, with more than 50% of our population living within 3.5 kilometres off the coast, Singapore feels this as acutely as other small island states in the Indian Ocean. Given that AR6 has concluded that it is “virtually certain” that global mean sea levels will continue to rise until at least 2100, we will have to grapple with this problem. Countries in the Indian Ocean region must work together urgently to support the full implementation of the Paris Agreement and strengthen our collective resilience against rising sea levels. From November to December 2023, the UNFCCC COP-28 in Dubai will aim to make progress on raising mitigation ambition and implementation, scaling up adaptation efforts, operationalising the new funding arrangements, as well as boosting climate finance, technology, and capacity building support for developing countries.

Bangladesh and Its Role

Bangladesh’s early history, culture and legacy are closely intertwined with the ebb and flow of its 700 rivers into the Bay of Bengal at the mouth of the Indian Ocean. The silt-rich waters from the Himalayas flowing through Bangladesh made it one of the most fertile lands in the sub-continent famed for its agricultural resources. Ancient Bengal achieved remarkable influence through a web of riverine and maritime lanes extending through the Bay of Bengal and to points further east. Today, modern Bangladesh is a strategic maritime nation promoting sustainable and equitable utilisation of oceanic resources.

As one of the fastest-growing economies in the world, Bangladesh plays an increasingly significant role in the Indian Ocean. Major projects are underway in Bangladesh which will improve the overall connectivity in the Indian Ocean region. Among them are the development of the Matarbari deep seaport in Cox’s Bazar, and upgrades to Chittagong Port as the principal seaport handling 92% of the country’s trade. This will put Bangladesh in good stead to provide maritime trade routes and facilities to the land-locked Northeast of India, as well as to Nepal and Bhutan. At the same time, we appreciate Bangladesh’s contributions to regional and subregional cooperation. It played a pivotal role in the formation of the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation or SAARC, the Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation or BIMSTEC and the Indian Ocean Rim Association.

Singapore’s interest in the Indian Ocean

As a small island state situated at the crossroads of the Indian and Pacific Oceans, Singapore’s survival and prosperity have always been inextricably linked to the oceans. Sea-freight accounts for a large proportion of our imports, including of essential supplies. With trade more than thrice our GDP, ensuring the safety and security of key trade routes such as the Straits of Malacca and Singapore is of vital importance to Singapore.

Singapore is therefore firmly committed to the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea or UNCLOS, which provides the legal framework within which all activities in the oceans and seas must be carried out.  UNCLOS is fundamental for upholding the right of all States to freedom of navigation and overflight, maintaining open trade routes and sea lines of communication, and promoting the conservation and sustainable use of the oceans and their resources. Singapore is strongly committed to working with like-minded partners to ensure that all maritime activities in the Indian Ocean are carried out in accordance with international law, including UNCLOS.

UNCLOS has also proven to be dynamic and highly adaptable in responding to emerging issues. On 4 March 2023, the Intergovernmental Conference presided over by Singapore’s Ambassador for Oceans and Law of the Sea Issues Rena Lee successfully concluded negotiations on a new international agreement under UNCLOS on the conservation and sustainable use of marine biodiversity of areas beyond national jurisdiction, or BBNJ. The BBNJ Agreement is a landmark achievement in oceans law and will provide a critical boost to global efforts to protect the marine environment.

Southeast Asia lies in the center of the Asia Pacific and the Indian Ocean, and serves as a very important conduit and portal to the two regions. We have consistently advocated for an open and inclusive regional architecture and engaging external partners, to give everyone a greater stake in the region’s peace, stability, and development. As the international order increasingly comes under strain, it is even more important that all of us redouble efforts to engage constructively, and uphold the ASEAN-led open, inclusive, and rules-based regional architecture. In 2019, ASEAN Leaders agreed on an ASEAN Outlook on the Indo-Pacific, which outlines ASEAN’s perspectives on how external partners should engage the region on its own merits.

Conclusion

We are all in agreement that we want an Indian Ocean built on peace, stability, and prosperity. We owe it to our people and the future generation to ensure we succeed in doing so. We have remained committed to enhancing dialogue, building trust, and upholding a rules-based international order. We must also continue to engage our counterparts from other regions.

 

Author Brief Bio: Dr Maliki Bin Osman is the Minister in the Prime Minister’s Office, Second Minister for Foreign Affairs and Second Minister for Education, Government of Singapore.

Note: This article is based on the Text of the Speech delivered by Dr Maliki Bin Osman, Minister in the Prime Minister’s Office, Second Minister for Foreign Affairs and Second Minister for Education, Government of Singapore at the 6th Indian Ocean Conference 2023 in Dhaka on 13 May 2023.

Indian Ocean Regionalism: A Sri Lankan Perspective

As we all know, the Indian Ocean is distinct to define the future of the world and Sri Lanka located in the center of the Indian Ocean is well poised to play a significant role of cooperation. Peace, prosperity and partnership in the Indian Ocean is in our mutual interest. This region has enormous economic potential and is the lifeline of global trade. The Indian Ocean region has always been a significant place of interest for all the countries. And today in the emerging multipolar world where Asia has become a major economic power, managing competition and strengthening cooperation is essential to the peaceful development of the region.

The countries in the Indian Ocean region have historically played a significant role in the global trade and commerce and having given rise to some of the great civilizations of the world. Sri Lanka has reiterated time and again that it is time for the Indian Ocean countries to take role determining their own future. Sri Lanka will be taking over the Chair of the Indian Ocean Rim Association later this year which gives us an opportunity to protect our common interest.

The Indian Ocean is a vital conduit for international trade and it is home to vast reserves of natural resources. It is imperative to ensure that the Indian Ocean sustain its status as a peaceful and prosperous region where all nations can equitably benefit from its abundant resources in a sustainable manner. Therefore, we must commit ourselves to ensure the rights and responsibilities of all states for sustainable use of the ocean. Many countries remain independent on energy supplies and traded goods that are carried across the region.

Those who are geographically located in the region have a primary interest in the security of the ocean which is more often than not linked to their economies and livelihood of their people. It is worth noting that the countries located along the shores of this great ocean, are among the most densely populated region on Earth. The nations of the region have emerged as some of the world’s fastest growing nations and continue to make remarkable progress in various sectors. Sri Lanka notes the recent entry into the force of the ASEAN led Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership RCEP and considers that this could serve as a catalyst for economic integration in Asia. Furthermore, the ongoing discussions between ADB, AIIB and BRICS on building synergies for growth is an important development.

Business in the region must grow for the region to develop its economic strength. Business require capital for expansion, this is why Sri Lanka has consistently urged for the incorporation of an Indian Ocean Development Fund for the development of the region and in particular establishing a strong humanitarian assistance and disaster management mechanism to deal with the natural and man-made disasters. Sri Lanka also believes that there is a significant need for enhanced Indian Ocean regionalism and focuses on augmenting cooperation across the maritime domain. Such regionalism should strive to create a closer linkage between ASEAN, IORA and BIMSTEC.

The Indian Ocean plays a pivotal role in the world economy and global growth. Our collaborative efforts will fully harness the immense potential of the region and further strengthen the bonds of cooperation and friendship among us. Sri Lanka’s historical and cultural significance as a central hub for the connectivity in the Indian Ocean cannot be overstated. Our strong partnership with the Indian Ocean Rim countries has enabled us to play an important role in the region’s multilateral engagements. Sri Lanka is committed to further strengthening these partnerships and engaging with regional community to promote peace, prosperity, and development in the region, particularly as we take up the chair of the IORA later this year. It is important to note the need for vigilance regarding the security of the Indian Ocean.

As littoral nations, we have a shared responsibility to ensure the safety and security of the Indian Ocean. The maintenance of peace and harmony in the region is of paramount importance to all the countries around the ocean. As per recent report from the World Bank, the Economic outlook for South Asia is shaped by the combination of positive and negative factors. The lower commodity prices, robust recovery in the service sector and improved supply chain stability are aiding the region’s growth. Rising interest rates and financial market uncertainties are exerting downward pressure on the region’s economy.

Sri Lanka is keen to engage with all littoral states and foster trade with all our partners to further enhance the economic activity in the Indian Ocean region. The emergence of blue and green economy offers a unique opportunity to address complex and interconnected economic challenges, perhaps climate resilient green economic policies could bring economic growth and prosperity to the Indian Ocean region with sustainable growth which is the new focus of the global policy discourse. Countries have embarked upon the development of more integrated ocean governance framework which will help avoid or at least limit intersectoral conflicts. At the outset and to highlight any trans boundary implications of coastal ocean development, countries seeking to develop their blue economies, acknowledge the need for the policies that better align future economic growth in their seats with maintaining or even restoring ocean health.

Sri Lanka already made significant progress in terms of the development of a national blue green economy initiative. Being a climate vulnerable country, Sri Lanka has seized the opportunity for sustainable economic growth through climate resilience. With the vision of the change and development, despite the climate insecure environment we are facing, we have focused on climate smart development through renewables. Therefore, it is vital to shift the renewable energy sector to address the current critical economic crisis, to alleviate poverty with the view to bring about prosperity in the nation and the world. As we are aware, climate change contributes to have profound impact on the Indian Ocean region, with adverse consequences for our environment communities and economies.

In order to address the challenges posed by climate change, it is imperative that we build appropriate capacity in the region. During COP-27, His Excellency Ranil Wickremesinghe, the President of Sri Lanka, announced his intention to establish an international climate change university in Sri Lanka. The innovative initiative will support green and blue studies and serve as a platform for research and policy advocacy related to climate change in the region. We believe that establishment of this university will be a valuable contribution to the regional and global effort to combat climate change. And we call upon support and cooperation of our regional partners in making this vision a reality. We look forward to working together to build a more sustainable and resilient future for the Indian Ocean region. We firmly believe that the working together towards these common goals, we can achieve sustainable peace and prosperity in our region. We are optimistic that through collaborative efforts we can create an environment conducive to economic growth, innovation, and progress for all the nations in the Indian Ocean region.

We all should look together, work together with other major maritime nations beyond the region and with the multilateral institutions to promote the economic prosperity and harmony in the Indian Ocean. Therefore, I urge all of us to come together and build and share vision of cooperation and promote economic growth, security, and stability in the Indian Ocean. By working towards these common goals, we can create a brighter future for ourselves and for generations to come. Let us continue to engage in productive and collaborative discussions and explore new avenues for cooperation and partnership. Together we can build a strong and more prosperous Indian Ocean region.

Author Brief Bio: Mr. Nimal Siripala de Silva is the Minister of Ports, Shipping and Aviation, Government of Sri Lanka.

Note: This article is based on the Text of the Speech delivered by Mr. Nimal Siripala de Silva, Minister of Ports, Shipping and Aviation, Government of Sri Lanka, at the 6th Indian Ocean Conference 2023 in Dhaka on 13 May 2023.

Explide
Drag